Those of you who don't have access to the private blog might not know what this is about. Here is an extract (with footnotes) from chapter one:
Russell pursued business interests up to his death.
Some of them were successful and some not. Sometimes the failures were
spectacular. But for all the considerable record left by these ventures, no
fraud exists. The worst that one can find is apparently evasive testimony
during the Russell divorce trial, and even that is open to debate. More telling
are Russell’s comments that go to motive. While Russell sought to “do good”
with money, he found the opportunities limited: “Those who have money … will
not find very much opportunity so far as the world is concerned. Even if we had
millions of dollars the spirit of a sound mind should govern us in its
expenditure. To give money to encourage anybody in wastefulness, slothfulness
and idleness would be to misuse it, and not to do good.” He found by observation,
or maybe experience, that wealthy people “cannot do even for [their] own
families all that [they] would wish to do.” It is unclear if he meant his own
relations or was speaking generally, though he concludes with “we could never
do sufficient for them.” Many were made newly poor in the post Civil War
depression. Knowing how to handle requests for money from family or friends was
difficult. “Before we became Christians at all, we may have been
under-balanced, or over balanced,” he wrote. “We may not have known how to deal
properly with our families or our friends. Out of kindness and sympathy we may
have been inclined to give them money, or to yield to their wishes in a way
that was injurious to them; or we may have been too severe and unyielding.”[1] He
may have been thinking of his Uncle Thomas Birney’s bankruptcy. Birney &
Co., Thomas’s wholesale hardware store, was closed by the sheriff in January
1886 “on executions aggregating $25,000.” Some sources give an unpaid
indebtedness of ninety-five thousand dollars.[2] Whatever happened over his uncle’s
bankruptcy, Russell was charitable, usually in quiet ways. During his 1907
court appearance questioning from the opposition attorney elicited this.[3]
[1] C. T. Russell: The Importance of Attaining Balance of
Mind, The Watch Tower, March 1, 1914, page 77.
[2] Birney had unwisely furnished roller skates to skating
rinks on credit. Skating was a fad, and he saw dollar signs. Payment was not
forth-coming and he could not maintain his business. Russell would not have had
enough money to save the Birney business. We don’t even know if his uncle
sought assistance. See Pith of the News, New York Herald-Tribune,
January 7, 1886; Bankrupt by Roller Rinks, Pennsylvania Patriot, January
7, 1886.
[3] Russell v. Russell Transcript of Record (1907), page
24: R: I usually gave my money away. Atty: You never gave it away, Mr. Russell,
until after your wife left you? R: Yes, sir, lots of it.
2 comments:
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v300/crimsonrose/ThomasBirney_zps51316800.jpg
Here is the image with the red removed I also straightened it a bit
thanks for your help!
Post a Comment