by Bernhard
(edited by Jerome)
RUSSELL, MARIA FRANCES
December 1884 – November 1897
When
Charles T. Russell became president of Zion’s Watch Tower Tract Society, on
December 15, 1884, his wife Maria Frances became secretary and treasurer. In
general, she was his secretary, who proofread his manuscripts and did the usual
work of an office assistant. On some chapters in the Millennial Dawn series she
co-labored with Charles in arranging them in final form and especially so for
volume IV, which consisted largely of quotations from newspaper clippings which
they had selected for some years. In evaluating the true function of Maria, it
appears that she acted in the capacity of special assistant to Charles as his
loyal wife. She was studious, college trained, and capable in her own right. No
doubt Charles utilized her talents to the fullest, not only in secretarial
functions, but in acting as organizer and arranger of his manuscript notes.
When
Maria separated from Charles in November 1897, he needed another secretary, and
this was Ernest C. Henninges.
HENNINGES, ERNEST CHARLES
November 1897 – April 1900
Ernest
was born on July 12, 1871 in Cuyahoga (Cleveland) Ohio and died on February 3, 1939
in Victoria, Australia. His father Emil Henninges (1828 – 1892) came from
Germany. His mother Kate was born 1840 in Ohio. He had one brother George (born
1858). Ernest’s profession was teaching music in Cleveland at 44 Euclid Avenue.
After
he joined the Bible Students he moved to Allegheny in 1891 to work and live in
the Bible House. On January 4, 1896, he replaced James Augustus Weimar as a
director of the Zion’s Watch Tower Tract Society and in May 13, 1898, 6 months
after Maria left the Bible House, Ernest succeeded her as secretary-treasurer.
Russell trusted him a lot.
In
the Bible House also lived Rose Ball, the foster child of Charles T. and Maria
Russell. On September 11, 1897, Ernest and Rose were married at Buffalo, Erie,
New York, where her parents Richard J. Ball and Elizabeth Ball still lived.
At the beginning of 1900, Russell planned to send Ernest and
Rose Henninges to England to open an office for the Society. So it was clear
that another brother needed to become secretary-treasurer, and this was Otto
Albert Koetitz on February 12, 1900, and also another brother, Albert E.
Williamson, became Russell’s private secretary. Ernest remained a director.
In
April 1900 Ernest and Rose travelled to Liverpool and then to London, where
they opened on April 23, the first office outside the United States, at 131 Gipsy Lane, Forest Gate. They stayed there
until November 1, 1901, and then came back to Allegheny. Ernest again became treasurer
of the Society on February 12, 1902 and remained such until March 24, 1903. On
that date William Van Amburgh became treasurer. In March 1903 Ernest and Rose
travelled to Elberfeld (Wuppertal), Germany, and again opened an office for the
Society in June 1903. They stayed there until October and then went to Melbourne,
Australia, arriving on January 10, 1904.
In
1908 some internal troubles surfaced. James Hezekiah Giesey, Watch Tower vice-president
and well-known Pittsburgh architect, along with long time director Simon
Osborne Blunden, resigned as Society directors in June. Albert Williamson
followed in September. Henninges also resigned as a director in January 1909,
and he and his wife left Russell and the Bible Students in the spring of 1909. Henninges
founded a new group and journal called “New Covenant Advocate” in Australia and
those in America like Giesey, Williamson, along with hymn writer M.L. Mc Phail,
formed a similar breakaway group.
WILLIAMSON, ALBERT EDMUND
April 1900 – September 1908
Albert
Williamson was born on February 13, 1878 in Oneida Township, Haldimand,
Balloville, Ontario, Canada. He was the son of James and Elizabeth Bayly (born
1839) and he had a twin brother Frederik William and also a sister Annie.
Albert married Hattie (Harriet) Stark (born Allegheny, December 1879) a member
of the Bible House family on December 5, 1905. She lived there with her mother
Britee C. Stark. Albert and Harriet had
three daughters Dorothy Eleanor (September 9, 1911), Elizabeth K. (1916) and
Edith Anna (1920).
He became a member of the Bible House staff in 1899, along with his mother,
and later, in 1905, his brother Fred. On February 12, 1900 he became a Watch
Tower Society director. He resigned on September 28, 1908. Interesting is that
his twin brother Frederick William replaced him as a Society director for one
year.
When Ernest C. Henninges travelled to England in April 1900, Albert Edmund
Williamson replaced him as Russell‘s private secretary.
The "Crittenden Record, Kentucky“, for February 8, 1907, contained a
report about a talk Williamson gave.
Under the heading: THE END OF THE WORLD IS NEAR AT HAND it explained: “October
1914 is the date set for the end to come. The Watch Tower Bible and Tract Society of Alleghany, Penn.,
through Mr. A. Edmund Williamson, announce the above date to be the beginning
of the millennium. Mr. Williamson, who is secretary to Charles T. Russell, head
of the society, did not, however, announce that there would be a general
conflagration of the earth and an incineration of all the wicked on that date,
but rather a "great change.""
Williamson was a very eloquent speaker, but more important was his skill as
a stenographer. Russell wrote about him (Souvenir
Convention Report from 1908): "In
my publishing office we have ten stenoographers, but only one of them could
serve in such an emergency—Mr. Williamson—and he consented to assist also. So
far as I know none of these gentlemen expect or have received pay for the
service, and only Mr. Williamson even has his expenses provided.“ Also in 1908 Russell wrote that he received about
500 letters every Monday and the rest of the week from 250 to 300 a day. So
there was a lot of work for him and his secretary.
Sadly
in late 1908 Williamson decided to leave the Bible House, but not only the
house, he also split from Russell in early 1909. He died in March 1956,
when he lived in Essex, West Orange, New Jersey.
ROBISON, FREDERI(C)K HOMER Prof.
September 1908 – 1914 (?)
Much of Robison‘s history comes from Robison’s obituary
in the Concordant Version magazine “Unsearchable Riches“ in 1932, because he was
to leave association with the IBSA in 1922. He was born on February 3, 1885 in
Greenwood, Indiana and died April 17, 1932 in Manhattan, New York. He was the only son of James A. Robison (1859-1949) and Eva J. Whitenack
(1862-1955), of Oakland, California. He had two sisters named Bartha B. and May
E. It was there that he spent his youth, graduating from high school at the age
of fourteen. It was about this time that he affiliated with the Disciples of
Christ. He entered Franklin College to continue his education and there further
displayed an aptitude for languages in the study of New Testament Greek.
Later he went to Canada and took out a claim in the Rainy River
district of Ontario. He resided there about one year, teaching part time and
part time employed in the immigration service. He returned to Indiana in 1904
and entered Butler College in Indianapolis, remaining there until the opening
of Winona Technical Institute, also in Indianapolis, and enrolled there as a
student of lithography that he might be equipped not only for his present need,
but to have the knowledge of a trade, for use in the missionary field. It was
his purpose to carry the gospel to Japan independently.
With
a year's instruction at the John Herrin Art Institute in Indianapolis and some
knowledge of chemistry to his credit, he made splendid progress and in less
than two years accepted a position as poster artist in one of the largest
lithographing houses in the United States, located at Cleveland, Ohio. He
became one of their foremen in charge of artists. It was while in this position
that he pursued the reading of Pastor Russell's works, having become slightly
interested during his sojourn in Canada. During all this time his linguistic
talents were being exercised more or less in the attainment of a knowledge of
Spanish, French and German, as well as New Testament Greek. After reading
Pastor Russell's works, he employed a Japanese friend to translate some of the
literature into Japanese, still thinking of the foreign mission field, but
later abandoned this to become a home missionary, as a colporteur for Pastor
Russell's works.
After
about one year in this new field of endeavor, he prepared for secretarial
service and was called to the Bible House in Allegheny, Pennsylvania. It was
there that he met Miss Almeta Nation, whom he married on March 25, 1909. He
became private secretary to Pastor Russell and held that position until after
the Society's offices were transferred to Brooklyn, New York, in 1909. As
private secretary to Pastor Russell he accompanied him on a trip around the
world (December 1911 – March 1912) with a committee sent to investigate foreign
missions. Japan was one of the places visited.
On
his return, Robison became secretary of the foreign work and he had a good
opportunity for pursuing the study of languages. His obituary stated that he could
translate twenty-three in all, giving discourses in German, Greek, and English.
He made week-end pilgrimages in and about New York City, addressing both public
and private gatherings.
Robison
was one of four men designated in Russell‘s will to be co-editors of the Watch
Tower. Apart from when imprisoned with J F Rutherford and others in 1918-1919,
he was one of the Watch Tower’s editorial committee until the spring of 1922
when he resigned and went to Washington, D. C., to accept secular work as a
commercial artist in the art department of the Washington Post. He afterwards
served the government and later became art director for the American Automobile
Association, with headquarters in Washington, D. C. He returned to work in New
York in 1931, and died on April 17, 1932.
When
the first installment of the literal Bible translation “The Concordant Version”
was issued it came to the attention of the Society’s headquarters. As the
plates of the Emphatic Diaglott were worn out, they were looking for something
to replace it, and Robison was delegated to call on the Concordant Publishing
Concern in Los Angeles with a view to placing it on the Society's list of
literature. A small booklet of the Concordant translation of Revelation was
advertised in the Watch Tower for June 15, 1920, but then was dropped in early
1921.
The
contact with the Concordant version group, who were Universalists, led to
Robison leaving association with the IBSA, resigning from the Watch Tower
editorial committee and as an elder of the New York congregation. He spent the
rest of the 1920s supporting the Concordant cause and trying to attract his
former IBSA associates to it. (For a fuller description of what happened and
how the Watch Tower Society dealt with it, use the search facility to see an
old article on this blog: The Watchtower and Universalism – the Almont
Connection.)
STURGEON, MENTA
1914 (?) – October 1916
Menta
Sturgeon was born
1866/67 in Missouri and died on April 17, 1935. He married Florence A. (born
1871 in Massachusetts) in 1888 and they had one son Gordon (born 1899).
Sturgeon
graduated from the Theological Seminary of the Southern Baptist Church and
studied Greek and Hebrew. In the late 1880s, he worked for the Kansas &
Texas Coal Company, and lived at 4001 N. B 'Way, St. Louis, Missouri. In March
1897 the members of his church unanimously appointed him a pastor, a position
he assumed until his resignation in 1904. He was reverend of a Baptist Church
in the city, the Tower Grove Baptist Church, located at 4320 avenue. However,
he left the church after internal dissension.
He
came into contact with Russell's teachings in 1894 through a small book handed
to him by his physician, but it was only 14 years later that he attended his
teaching when he attended readings Biblical records given by the pastor at Arch
Street: first as a simple listener, then as the pastor's interlocutor. In the
meantime, he preached independently, and then added his own disciples to
Russell's group. Finally, he received a letter from the pastor asking him if he
could become a lecturer for him, which Sturgeon accepted, and so in 1909 he
left the society in which he worked; apparently it was the Blackmer & Post
Pipe Company.
He
was a member of the Saint Louis Ecclesia. As a pilgrim, from 1909-1914 he
visited central and eastern states of
the United States, as well as various provinces of Canada. He was a capable
speaker. He came to work at the Watch Tower headquarters around 1910, where he
first worked on general supervision and then conducted Bible classes and
religious services.
In
addition to being Russell's secretary, Sturgeon was also responsible for
helping the latter in his medical treatments. He was the last of the Bible
Students to see Russell alive. On Russell’s last tour, he had to replace him at
times in Los Angeles, and was with him when he died on the train on the return
journey to Brooklyn. Sturgeon reported in detail the last days of his life in
the Watch Tower publications.
In
the split that followed Rutherford’s election as president, Sturgeon supported
the four dismissed directors, and was put forward as an alternative choice as
president. In the subseqent referendum comparatively few voted for him.
Sturgeon was to
leave both the Watch Tower Society and the alternative Bible Student groups, to
join Fredrik Robison in supporting the Concordant Publishing Concern. He died
on August 17, 1935 and the group’s magazine published an obituary from which
some of the above has been taken.
14 comments:
Excellent research - it seems that none of his secretaries, despite having such close contact with him, remained with the belief system. In some ways it seems to have been sad for all parties concerned (of course, those who followed universalist theology wouldn't mind, because they believed all would be put right eventually). Thank you for filling in some of the gaps in the story - especially with the high-quality photographs.
To Andrew: I noted that too, although I wonder whether Robison and Sturgeon would have left the way they did if CTR had lived longer. To balance that slightly, one of CTR's "unofficial" secretaries for several years was John Adam Bohnet, especially during the last few years of Maria's tenure. Bohnet remained with the Watch Tower Society right through to the "new name" Jehovah's Witnesses. He deserves his own article which hopefully will one day appear here.
Jerome - I wonder that, too. Things might have been so different. I have tended to think that the departure of Robison, the Society's linguist, was a major setback (albeit temporary) in the worldwide work. Of course, if they were carried along simply because of affinity for CTR's personality, how enduring was their adherence in reality? [A side note for current Witnesses: last week's WT lesson somewhat addressed that issue when it discussed recurring personality conflicts - and I suspect much of the post-Russell dissension was based largely on that: personality conflicts that were allowed to get out of hand.]
Thanks Bernhard!
This article would be better if footnoted to original sources. Can we add footnotes referencing original source material?
Excellent, Bernhard and Jerome!!
Footnotes will be useful.
A question. Robinson had knowledge of several languages as spanish. Is there any possibility that he translated some of Russell's works to spanish? It would be of interest for me.
And also, Henninges was a music teacher at Cleveland. Could you supply sources for this?
Thanks
Miquel
The source for Henninges: City directories for Cleveland, Ohio (1890), Cleveland Directory Co, page 1020. And also 1891, page 403 and 1100.
All other dates are from the documentation: “135 years Watchtower Bible & Tract Society, a documentation on its directors and the members of the governing body.“
Try not to search for this book!
Excellent work from Bernhard. Thank you to him and Jerome for his help too. These guys are certainly interesting.
From experience, I sometimes wonder if the hard work involved in being a Secretary is always appreciated? Also, whether it can somehow, sometimes contribute to feelings of frustration, self importance and disloyalty? Even so, I much prefer to concentrate on examples of a number of secretaries, ancient and comparatively modern, who remained loyal and stood the test of time, notably Baruch, Bohnet and Macmillan. Articles on the later two would be most appreciated and might add useful counter balance.
All good wishes,
Gary
Only that the story is complete: we forgot to mention another special secretary from Russell l.ike John Bohnet. This was Edwin W. Brenneisen.
Hello Bernhard.
I need sources confirm that J. A. Bohnet was Russell's secretary? Please, write if you know them. Thanks.
For Karol
J A Bohnet acted as a secretary at times during the 1890s, having learned shorthand/stenography so he could join the Bible House family. He explains this in his life story as found in the St Paul Enterprise Newspaper, August 15, 1915.
A Polish web site describes me as a “liberal JW.” I’m uncertain what is meant. If the writer suggests that I have a liberal view of the Bible, they are incorrect. If they mean that I have a lax view of moral obligations, that too is incorrect. If they mean that I have a loosely held view of congregation structure; that is wrong-headed. I am, in fact, socially conservative, a Bible believer. I believe that all the rights and obligations God grants apply to everyone. In the United States the appellation “liberal elder” or “liberal Witness” attaches to a type of apostate. Are you calling me an apostate? On what basis?
A private email suggested that I was angry at the Watchtower Society. The basis is a footnote in my current work. Perhaps the person who wrote that email is a mind reader, but I doubt the possibility.
Related to the above, but from another, is the suggestion that I should not repeat something previously said in volume two’s footnotes. This ignores the nature of volume two which is a series of essays presented in rough chronological order. My experience with that type of writing is that it may not be read in chapter order. So I have repeated key footnotes. I will not change that. If one of them reflects on your beliefs, it says no more that what is true.
The Separate Identity series occasionally challenges Russell mythology. Some who read them, some who visit this blog, are committed to the various mythologies, both pro and anti Russell. I am not. I am committed to telling you an accurate, clearly stated account. If you want to challenge the narrative as I present it, give me your sources. I will accept only original sources. Secondary sources, especially one written by a polemicist, are of no value.
Menta Sturgeon has two death dates. This is correct on August 17th.
and Leslie W. Jones, secretary during numerous trips, including around the world 1911-1912
Post a Comment